“Why Does God Allow Children to Suffer?” Bishop’s Reflection on Faith and Cancer
In a recent interaction, James, a student from OLSH Catholic College in Alice Springs, posed a profound question to Cathcroc, the beloved mascot known for engaging with the community on matters of faith and spirituality. The question was then directed to Bishop Charles Gauci, who provided a compassionate and insightful response.
James asked, “Why does God give cancer to children?” This heartfelt inquiry, filled with the innocence and curiosity of youth, was met with an understanding nod from Cathcroc, who promptly turned to Bishop Gauci for a thoughtful answer.
Bishop Gauci began by gently clarifying, “James, God doesn’t give cancer to people or children or anyone. God doesn’t give illness to anyone. Nature does that. Nature is limited. And as we know, things can go wrong in nature.”
Drawing from personal experience, Bishop Gauci shared, “My sister died as a baby. My brother died as a four-and-a-half-year-old boy. God did not kill them. Illness killed them. Human reality took their life, not God’s plan.” His words highlighted a fundamental distinction between natural occurrences and divine intention, emphasising that suffering and illness are not orchestrated by God.
Bishop Gauci offered reassurance by saying, “But what God has promised is to be with us and guide us even when these things happen.” He conveyed a message of hope and eternal life, affirming, “I am sure I will see my sister in heaven and my brother in heaven because God is looking after them.”
In addressing the broader question of suffering, Bishop Gauci noted, “The message of Jesus tells us that no, God does not give us illness. The limitation of nature does that.” This explanation underscores a theological perspective that sees God as a source of comfort and guidance rather than a cause of suffering.
The session concluded with an invitation from Cathcroc and Bishop Gauci for further engagement. “If you have any questions about God and the beautiful creations around us, feel free to get in touch.
This interaction at OLSH Catholic College serves as a poignant reminder of the enduring questions that shape our understanding of faith, suffering, and the nature of God’s presence in our lives. It also highlights the importance of compassionate dialogue in addressing the profound questions that arise from the experiences of pain and loss.